He Loves Me, He Loves Me Not

He Loves Me, He Loves Me Not

By Karen Backman 

My father always said that there are two kinds of people in the world: Those who divide people into two groups, and those who don’t. My father said a lot of things. “I love you” was never one of them. Some families say those sorts of things to each other, and some don’t. Ours never did. That’s not to say we didn’t love each other. We did. We just never learned to talk about it.

Perhaps it’s the Scandinavian background that informs our actions. They are renowned for their stoicism, after all. Pain, joy, and frustration look the same on a Swede. Neutral. That’s my father to a tee. Me, I learned to act reserved by watching my dad. I think we all did. But none of us could really match his neutrality. Perhaps it was our mixed blood that did us in. I always joke that my mother has Latin bloodlines in her family somewhere — fiery, passionate, difficult to contain. I was cursed with it, to be sure. Like many people, my father assumed that tears and rational thinking were mutually exclusive options. I lived in fear of his contempt, to which my tears made me susceptible.

That is why I will never forget my niece’s birth. My younger sister, Tanya, was six months pregnant with her first child when my three-year relationship with David ended. Within days, he was dating Tanya’s sister-in-law, Rachel. Days! (It was only later that I discovered he’d been secretly courting her for months. ‘Keeping his options open’, he called it.)

In the eighth month of Tanya’s pregnancy, David proposed to Rachel, and she accepted. While I was still reeling from this blow, it occurred to me that David and I might both end up at the hospital when Tanya went into labor. After all, it was the first child for both Tanya and her husband, and so it was a big deal for both families. I was certain David would accompany Rachel to the hospital. If not to gloat outright, then at least to emphasize that he had made his choice, and I wasn’t it. I could just see him, joking with his future in-laws, while I seethed in a corner alone.

I am an expert at avoidance, but I could see no way to avoid David in this situation. I could also envision no way of handling the meeting graciously. I decided to call him and ask him to stay away. After all, I reasoned, I was REALLY family, and he was only family-to-be. I obviously had more right than he to be at the hospital.

“Hi, Dave,” I began, my voice cracking. “I called to ask you a favor.” I took a deep breath while I waited for him to acknowledge me. I had to hold it together — if I cried, I would be at his mercy. When he didn’t respond, I charged ahead, explaining the situation as I saw it. After I finished, he remained silent for what felt like forever. Finally, he spoke.

“Don’t you think you’re being a little bit selfish?” he asked, his voice edged with derision. “I mean, this is my family, too, or it will be soon.”

I was stunned. I don’t know what I had been expecting, but this certainly wasn’t it. I tried to fight the tears rising inside me, tried to remain calm, tried to find an appropriate response for such a cruel comment. It didn’t work. My emotions ricocheted from anger to hurt to incredulity, finally fusing into bitterness. I slammed the phone down, dissolved into sobs, and headed for my room.

As I passed my father’s study, he turned from his desk to peer at me. “What did he say?” he asked quietly, no trace of emotion in his voice. I waved my hand dismissively, too overcome to formulate an answer. A sob escaped my throat, and I started again toward my room. Out of the corner of my eye, I saw that he was on his feet. Instinctively, I froze. “What could he POSSIBLY say,” my dad continued, his voice rising, “Besides ‘I understand. I’ll stay away.’?” He was halfway to the door now. In my shock at my father’s reaction, it barely registered that my own tears had stopped. “I have half a mind to call Ruth and Paul right now, and tell them that if he shows up at the hospital, I’ll have him forcibly removed!” His voice was tight with barely-suppressed fury. He was in the hallway now, his arm around my shoulders, and suddenly I was sobbing uncontrollably.

“Don’t worry, honey,” he murmured into my hair. “I’ll take care of him. I’ll take care of everything.” It wasn’t ‘I love you’, but believe me, it was enough.

Return to Backman's Blurb